Royal Caribbean versus MSC making the choice between the two?
What is better for families MSC or Royal Caribbean?
Have you cruised on Royal Caribbean and want to try something else? What is the difference between MSC and Royal Caribbean? Do you choose MSC or Royal Caribbean? lets find out!
Lots of people cruise with Royal Caribbean its known as good for families but what about MSC? MSC is known as the family cruiseline. We have cruised with Royal Caribbean for 10 years and are diamond members so we love it! After doing a couple of days on the naming of MSC’s Bellissima we were intrigued and looked for something in a port in Spain near where we would be during the summer holidays. We took a cruise out of Valencia for seven days around the med so here is what we thought.
So what did we think and why is there so much hype about Royal Caribbean?
We booked the yacht club on MSC his time. This post is based on our experience as a whole but does include some of the suites benefit differences on both ships. On first look MSC is very glamourous and screams luxury! Did this experience continue? Yes it did!
We could not fault the service, drinks, the ship or the food. MSC surprised us in more ways than one.
What is the main difference between MSC and Royal Caribbean?
MSC is an Italian cruise company while Royal Caribbean is an American Company. The company was founded in Naples in Italy in 1989. MSC Cruises are the world’s largest privately held cruise company. They are also known for their glamorous ships and Swarovski staircases.
Royal Caribbean is a Public company that was founded in Miami, Florida in 1968. They are known for their entertainment, promenade parties, deck parties and fun!
Royal Caribbean do offer different ports of call in the Caribbean that are not offered by MSC. Likewise MSC offer ports of call in Europe and the Caribbean that are not offered by Royal Caribbean.
Your first decision should be where do you want to cruise? Then who do you want to cruise with?
What is the Price difference between MSC and Royal Caribbean?
How different is the pricing on Royal Caribbean vs MSC Cruises? It is difficult to say for definite but the pricing varies in my opinion. When it comes to suites there is a big price increase on Royal Caribbean compared to MSC but then there are a lot of differences between the cabins. The general opinion is that people search on both and MSC comes up cheaper for families and in addition they often have deals where kids under 12 often sail for free.
Whats the difference between Children’s clubs and activities on MSC versus Royal Caribbean.
Kids club! What is the difference between MSC and Royal Caribbean?
Main differences concerning children are that MSC offer babysitting for a fee. Royal Caribbean do not offer babysitting anymore unless you are in suite which is such a shame.
MSC children clubs are partnered with Lego, Duplo and Chicco so you have the best brands. The kids planners on both cruise lines are similar with activities for all ages.
On MSC we saw lots of children and babies in the bars late at night in buggies. This was nice the bars were not to busy and it was more relaxed.
There are similar activities on MSC as on RC for the teens but there are also different languages to deal with. Our teens found this no problem even though they thought it would be. On both cruise lines there are english speaking staff so smaller children should feel comfortable and so should you as a parent.
Our teen boys were worried embarking on MSC as on Royal Caribbean they had no problem making friends. However as with large groups of teens there can be problems. On MSC the children were from all different nationalities, Spanish, Italian, french and many more. The children conversed made friends and learnt many pockets of different languages.
My sons words before boarding MSC were “I was worried about coming on here and and now I don’t want to get off! Ive learnt more Spanish here in a week than I did a school!’
MSC has lots of cool stuff such as the 4D theatre and the formula one simulators. Royal Caribbean has laser and iceskating to name but a few
Drink packages on Royal Caribbean versus MSC.
Differences between the drink packages on MSC and Royal Caribbean.
MSC drink packages
Easy package which includes all drinks up to 6 euros. This would include wine and beers. ( €29 per day as of sep 2019)
The premium package which is all drinks priced up to 10 euros with selected spirits, juices coffees and teas.( €39 per day as of sep 2019)
The premium plus package which give you complete freedom with all liqueurs, aperitifs and cocktails with no price limit. You also receive 30% off of bottles of wine.( €55 per day as of sep 2019)
MSC Non alcoholic package adults, which includes alcohol free cocktails and sodas. ( €19 per day as of sep 2019)
MSC Non alcoholic package kids complete freedom for kids with alcohol free cocktails, sodas and fruit juice’s and even hot chocolates. ( €14 per day as of sep 2019)
Royal Caribbean drink packages
Deluxe beverage package which lets you enjoy any beverage onboard including cocktails, wines, spirits, soda, squeezed juices and premium tea and coffee. You also receive a discount on any bottles of wine you wish to purchase – 40% off of bottles priced up to $100 and 20% off of bottles priced over $100. This package can be as much as $85 dollars a day.
The refreshment package is a great idea for those who do not wish to purchase alcohol. You can enjoy any selection of premium coffees and teas along with bottled water, freshly squeezed juices, non alcoholic cocktails and any choice from the soda package.
The classic soda package includes unlimited soda fountain refills in your own souvenir cup. Perfect for kids.
Cafe select coffee card 15 types of specialty coffees, premium teas and hot chocolates. This Royal Caribbean coffee package lets you purchase a card that is punched as you go saving you up 50% on each drink. A one a time purchase card that can be shared between guests.
The drinks on both cruise lines are similar with cocktails and spirits. The wine on the MSC had a wider choice including more Mediterranean choices where as RC is more Californian wines.
Venchi ice-cream is included in Yacht club including the milkshakes.
The actual drink prices on MSC are cheaper with cocktails averaging at around 8 euros (7 pounds where as on Royal caribbean cocktails are around 13 dollars (£11.50)
Entertainment differences on MSc Vs Royal Caribbean.
The theatre experiences differ on MSC and Royal but mainly due to the mix of nationalities watching.
MSC shows are mainly song and dance acts and a lot is sung in English some will be in italian. The audience seem to clap more but I have seen children running up and down the aisles on MSC. There are no drink holders in the seats in the MSC theatre and there is no one serving drinks so you would need to get one before. The quality of the entertainment staff is amazing! and the shows are still top quality and include Magic shows and circus acts.
They also held themed nights such as the white pool party on deck.
There were Kids from the kids clubs on stage every night before show doing something they had learnt in kids club. Some people may not like this but its quite cute and the children seem to enjoy themselves. We personally did love this sort of thing when ours were little. Show starts later than the programmed time and you can rock up and get a seat late.
The newer MSC ships have Cirque du Soleil show’s which there is a small charge for.
We found the daytime activities lacking on MSC there were only one or two quizzes but this could be down to the language barriers.
Royal Caribbean night life and shows.
Royal Caribbean show are excellent quality, you will experience Ice shows, tribute acts and set shows every night. There is a lot of choice on Royal Caribbean. There are shows that are more suitable for children which tell a story as well as circus acts and magic shows. They hold parties on the promenades, sail away parties, themed nights and even silent discos.
You can get drinks in the theatre and there are holders for your glasses. You will also be served drinks as well in the theatre. In the daytime there are plenty of quizzes and activities.
Bars and Lounges comparison on MSC and Royal Caribbean
The MSC style is more relaxed and low key. The bars appear to be quieter there are pubs on the two newer ships offering music. The lounges are more like jazz and are not busy. They have a disco for all ages but adults only when late.
There are bars which sing in another language which are busier but there are English singing bars as well.
Pools, what is the difference between MSC and Royal Caribean?
MSC shut pools at night which I think is a great idea. Being the parent of a teens my fear is lots of kids gettting in the pool or jacuzzis late at night which is what generally happens on Royal Caribbean. As parents we find ourselves going out to check where they are and what they are doing.
MSC drain down the pools and net over the jacuzzis after the lifeguard has left. Often with peer pressure and children finally finding friends they want to sit in the hot tubs after dark. This is not something that sits right with me and often on all inclusive holidays and cruise I find myself worrying and trapsing around trying to find them.
This gives me a comfort to know that the pools are drained and covered. Obviously let your child know!
Royal Caribbean do not do this and there are often groups of kids in jacuzzis way in to the early hours.
All pools are similar and there are lots of sunbeds available on both. There were plenty of Jacuzzis on both cruise lines however I found MSC to be quieter during the day around the pool.
Ports of call on Royal Caribbean versus MSC
MSC does a port every day meaning you get lots of choice. You really don’t feel like you have to get off every day.
We love the flexibility of being able to book your holiday any day of the ships itinerary. It means that some people you meet on the ship may be getting off the next day. It’s a constant change of people daily which can be nice. This is also generally means no sea days.
Muster Drill and check in
The muster drill on MSC is everyday due to people embarking daily. Which can be a bit of a pain if you have decided to have your sunny nap on deck around 4 o’clock. You tend not to notice after a while but this flexibility means that you can board at any port and do your muster drill there and then so you can relax for the rest of the holiday. You have to take your lifejackets with you on MSC.
Royal Caribbean muster drill is just on embarkation day and you do not need your life jacket with you.
You will recieve your key card on arrival at the check in desk on Royal Caribbean. It is a very smooth check in even though there are lots of people all embarking on that one day.
MSC is just as straight forward but you need your printed tickets to get on to your ship. You will find your keycards in your state room.
Children’s muster bands are obtained on arrival on both MSC and Royal Caribbean. All of the muster announcements are made in many languages possibly more on MSC.
Buffet restaurants MSC had slightly less choice but good quality food and fantastic Italian pizza.
Royal Caribbean has a lot more choice in the buffet and included a range of food from different nationality’s such as Asian food.
The main dining room good quality in both restaurants with good service. The MSC choices of food on the menu was slighter less than Royal Caribbean. I had no complaints about the food in fact in my opinion it was better! Many people say thet the portion size is smaller but I didn’t mind, you can always ask for more! Freshly cooked meats and fish on MSC was fabulous.
The suites in Yacht club on MSC are considered to be all inclusive therefore you will have a fully stocked fridge in your room and a drinks package. Your fridge is replenished daily. You do not get WIFI with a suite. In the yacht club on MSC sparkling champagne is actually champagne and not sparkling wine, you can also get prosecco.
You can book a suite not in Yacht club but this will not get you access to the yacht club area. In suites not in Yacht club you would have the Fantastica and Aurea Experiences . These suites are on MSC Bellissima, MSC Grandiosa, MSC Virtuosa and MSC Magnifica with some cabins accommodating up to 5 people.
Royal Caribbean Suites can be even more pricey but you get access to the suite lounge and coastal kitchen if you have one. I felt like the MSC Yacht club had the edge over Royal it felt more exclusive.
A few more differences.
We found MSC to be less dressy in general however on formal night long trousers in the muse restaurant ( yacht club ) had to be worn.
Royal caribbean are quite relaxed but you do see more people dressed up for formal night.
There seemed to be more elevators throughout the ship on MSC however still busy when boarding.
You also get priority lifts on MSC in yacht club by swiping your key card.
If you get WiFi on Royal you pay by day and it will work on one device you can swap devices by logging out and you can purchase more packages.
On MSC you purchase your WIFI and you get a set amount to use with up to 4 devices. Our MSC WIFI ran out on day one as it used the data that the back ground apps were running. We didn’t even get the chance to surf the net. Royal Caribbeans WIFI packages work much better.
There seemed to be less toilets some often one toilet in some areas on MSC. Some areas did not seem to have the same level of cleanliness as Royal especially around by the busy pool areas.
MSC loyalty status match
If you are a frequent traveller on Royal caribbean and are a Crown and anchor member MSC will match your status. Get the match prior to first sailing online here.
Thank you for reading what is the difference between MSC and Royal Caribbean?
We will be traveling on a few more MSC ships before the year is out so we update this post with all that we find!